Under Contract
A Mid-Century Modern jewel set on nearly an acre of wooded grounds on Indy's most sought-after street, the house has three levels, two fireplaces, views outside through expansive windows, over 1500 sf of decks and patios, and original lights and woodwork.

Designed for this lot by noted Mid-Century Modern architect John Hirsch, this home promotes indoor/outdoor living with its views and easy access points to patios and decks. The neighborhood is beautiful and the neighbors know and care about one another. The central location allows you to be in downtown Indy or up in Carmel in fifteen to twenty minutes. It is located within easy walking distance to Broad Ripple, with its restaurants and shopping, as well as the Red Line that opens in September. Situated on a hill less than 1000 feet from the White River, its woods are often visited by deer and rabbits.

Built in 1954, the house is a prime example of Midcentury Modern architecture, which gained critical and then popular attention after World War II. Many traditional elements of MCM architecture are found here, including a specific design for the hillside lot, open areas (long before the open concept touted today), soaring and overhanging rooflines that allow direct sun in winter but only light in summer (long before todays environmental designs), lots of glass to draw the outdoors in, moveable walls for various room uses, and multiple access points to outdoor spaces. It was designed by noted architect John Hirsch of New Jersey, known for his MCM public buildings in that state. The use of nineteenth-century bricks adds yet another layer of historical interest to the home. Correspondence about the house and its multiple plans are held in the State Library, the city's Museum of Art, and by the current owners.

The house has a great deal of history and character. The original family, leaders in Indy business, religious, and philanthropic communities, lived there for 52 years. The home, with its open spaces and easy access to the outdoors, lends itself to entertaining. Indeed, a single door in the hall closes access to the private portions of the house, leaving the rest open to visitors. From its two large decks and three covered stone porches, to its large main floor fireplace and cozy downstairs fireplace, the home was designed for family, friends, and fun.

Purchased in 2006 by its present owners, the house has seen a facelift without changing its character. All of the original design elements remain, including the original Thermador oven and stove (they don't build them like that anymore!), moveable walls, halls with skylights, washer and dryer in the kitchen, colorful original laminate tiles, floating closets, and walls repurposing historic bricks. Attention was paid to new thermal windows and Brazilian teak floors in the living room, a new marmoleum floor in the kitchen (returning to the historic green that was found below layers of linoleum), replacing woodwork around the house, replacing an old deck with a large cantilevered deck in keeping with the style, and opening up the overgrown lot to the south with trails enjoyed by dogs and kids. Updating the property has resulted in a virtual bird, rabbit, squirrel, and deer haven.

Restoring aspects of the 65-year-old historic home required a lot attention. It has been a labor of love for our family, and it has been a joy to watch peoples faces the first time they visit. It is a unique home. There remain a few items to be restored (including the front slate porch), which is why we have priced it as we have.

Why are we leaving a home we love? Its the familiar story of downsizing. With two kids approaching college and the availability of a smaller Midcentury Modern that will suit us better for the decades to come, we've decided to pass along the treasure we've enjoyed to another generation who appreciates this style of home and life.

The house is being offered in "as is" condition. There are no known structural defects; if any are detected during an inspection, the sellers will accommodate them.

More House Facts:
Air conditioner: 2016 (Carrier), serviced annually
Dual furnaces: 2004 (Carrier)*, serviced annually
Dishwasher: 2015 (Bosch)
Roof: early-2000s (40-year roof with metal sheeting, membrane, tar, and stone)
Sewage: new pipe through easement installed in 2014
Trees: the lot has dozens of trees, most of them mature, including: black walnut, Japanese maple, hickory, catalpa, broad-leaf magnolia, false cypress, arborvitae, mulberry, maple, beech, cottonwood, larch, large black oaks, pawpaw, several tall sycamores, one gigantic American elm, among others.

Interior Features

  • Stories: 3
  • Square Feet: 4,464
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 3.5
  • Additional Rooms: 9
    • BreakfastNook
    • MasterBath
    • Workshop
    • DiningRoom
    • FamilyRoom
    • Office
    • WalkInCloset
    • Library
    • RecreationRoom
  • Floor Coverings
    • Laminate
    • LinoleumVinyl
    • Hardwood
    • Slate
  • Appliances
    • Dishwasher
    • GarbageDisposal
    • Refrigerator
    • Dryer
    • RangeOven
    • Washer
  • Heating & Cooling
    • Central AC
    • Central Heating
  • Interior Keywords:
    • Fireplace
    • Security System
    • Jetted Bathtub
    • Basement

Exterior Features

  • Built in: 1954
  • Structure Type: House
  • Lot Size: 0.81 Acres
  • Parking: 2 Spaces
    • Carport
  • Exterior Keywords:
    • Porch
    • Deck
    • Patio

Explore: Meridian Hills / Williams Creek

Neighborhood Quick Facts

  • Median Sale Price
  • Commute via Transit:
  • Family Friendly Score
  • Fun & Hip Score

Area Schools

Merle Sidener Gifted Academy
Grades 2-8
GreatSchools Rating
Center For Inquiry Ii
Grades KG-8
GreatSchools Rating
North Central High School
Grades 9-12
GreatSchools Rating
Ernie Pyle School 90
Grades PK-6
GreatSchools Rating
Theodore Potter School 74
Grades KG-6
GreatSchools Rating
Frederick Douglass School 19
Grades PK-8
GreatSchools Rating
Fox Hill Elementary School
Grades KG-5
GreatSchools Rating
Northview Middle School
Grades 6-8
GreatSchools Rating
H L Harshman Middle School
Grades 7-8
GreatSchools Rating


  • Transit
  • Restaurants
  • Grocery Stores
  • Bars & Nightlife
  • Parks
  • Healthcare
  • Sports & Recreation
  • Neighborhood information provided by Home Junction Inc. © 2020. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
  • GreatSchools Ratings provided by GreatSchools.org
  • School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Home Junction Inc. and are subject to change. Check with the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.
  • All pictures, details or descriptions of any property, condition of title, value or otherwise is provided for informational purposes only and may not represent the true and current status of the property now or at the time of sale. Neither ForSaleByOwner.com, nor Seller’s Broker shall be liable for any allowance, adjustment or revision in value of any property based upon the failure of such property, its appliances, its fixtures or its floor plan to conform to any specific standard. ForSaleByOwner.com hereby disclaims any representations or warranties as it relates to all information found herein.
  • The information available on this page is for marketing purposes only.
  • Please contact the Listing Agent or Seller directly for inquiries regarding this property and/or to make an offer.
  • Fraud & Scam Awareness
    Unfortunately, there are people that will use internet sites like ForSaleByOwner.com to run all manner of scams on users. We do all that we can to prevent the willful misuse of our platform, however; every day, the scams get more and more sophisticated. We ask that our users be cognizant of the risk and review the following basic ways to recognize and avoid being scammed.
  • Recognizing and Avoiding Scams:

    • Use secure, traceable transactions when making payments - Do not pay a deposit by wire transfer, prepaid money card, gift card, or other non-traditional payment method. Also, refuse to make "overpayments" and never enter into "handshake" deals without a contract.
    • Don't accept suspect cashier/certified checks or money orders - Banks will process and cash the fakes, then hold you responsible.
    • Never give out financial or personally identifiable information - This includes banking and credit card information, your birthdate, Social Security/Social Insurance Numbers, PayPal account etc.
    • Suspicious communications - Watch for parties communicating using poor grammar, spelling or those who send nonsensical messages. Be wary of parties that are only willing to text/email and those that will never speak on the phone or that refuse to meet in person. Generally these people will claim to be "travelling" and unavailable to talk or located in a foreign country and unable to speak other than via text or email.
    • Deals Too Good to be True - If the list price is obviously too low, or the terms are too generous as compared to the market, it’s likely a scam.
    • Don’t be pressured to act immediately - Scammers typically try to make you think a listing is in high demand in order to push you into immediate action without consulting family, friends, or financial advisors. Say no to high pressure sales tactics.
  • Who Should I notify about fraud or scam attempts?

Mortgage Calculator

Let us help.

Call us toll free at
1 (888) FOR-SALE (1-888-367-7253)

Monday – Friday 8am - 8pm (Eastern Time)
Saturday – 11am – 3pm (Eastern Time)
Sunday – Closed

Tell me more about this property. Contact the seller